Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Modesto 209-222-3000
Modesto & Stockton Accident Lawyer
Stockton 209-850-2828
Schedule a Free Consultation
· Hablamos Español
Modesto & Stockton Accident Lawyer / Blog / Car Accidents / Partly to Blame, Still Paid: California’s Pure Comparative Fault Rule and What It Means for Your Modesto Accident Claim

Partly to Blame, Still Paid: California’s Pure Comparative Fault Rule and What It Means for Your Modesto Accident Claim

Liability_Book

Here is a question many injured people quietly worry about: what if the crash was partly my fault? Maybe you were a few miles over the limit or did not see the other car in time. In some states, that can end a claim. In California, it generally does not, because California follows a rule called pure comparative fault.

What Pure Comparative Fault Means

Under pure comparative fault, each person involved in an accident is assigned a percentage of responsibility, and an injured person’s compensation is reduced by their own percentage. The rule comes from a 1975 California Supreme Court decision, and it is applied by courts and juries throughout the state. Unlike modified systems that bar recovery once a person is 50 or 51 percent at fault, California has no such cutoff.

Suppose a jury finds total damages of $100,000 and that the injured driver was 30 percent at fault. The recovery is reduced to $70,000. At 60 percent fault, it would be $40,000. The percentages are decided from the evidence, which is why fault is so contested.

Fault Does Not Always Stay With One Person

Many Modesto crashes involve more than two drivers or a commercial vehicle. California Civil Code § 1431.2, known as Proposition 51, addresses how responsibility is shared among defendants: liability for noneconomic damages, such as pain and suffering, is generally limited to each defendant’s percentage of fault, while economic damages such as medical bills are not limited in the same way.

How Insurers Use Comparative Fault

Because every percentage point of blame reduces a claim, insurance adjusters often look for reasons to assign more fault to the injured person. Arguments commonly raised include:

  • Speeding or driving too fast for conditions
  • Distraction, such as phone use or other inattention
  • Failure to wear a seat belt, which can be raised to argue injuries were worse than they should have been
  • Sudden lane changes or braking
  • Failure to keep a proper lookout or to yield
  • Delays in medical care, or missed appointments

Early remarks such as “I didn’t see him” can be quoted later, and photos, witness accounts, and police reports can influence how percentages are assigned.

Pure comparative fault is not the only rule that matters. California Civil Code § 3333.4 limits noneconomic damages for certain uninsured drivers, most personal injury lawsuits must be filed within two years under Code of Civil Procedure § 335.1, and claims against government entities can have much shorter deadlines.

Blamed for Part of the Crash? Talk With Us Before You Talk With the Insurer

Being partly at fault does not necessarily mean your claim is over, but how fault is described and documented can shape the outcome. Our Modesto car accident attorneys at The Law Firm of R. Sam can explain how California’s rules may apply to your crash. Talk with The Law Firm of R. Sam, and we will walk through what happened. We serve injured people in Modesto, California and Stockton, California.

Source:

https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=CIV&sectionNum=1431.2